Share from 0:00
0:00
/

What we can learn from Clay’s new pricing model

If you pay per bite, you eat less pizza

🎬 WATCH THE VIDEO (click above) for the full teardown with my real reaction to Clay’s new AI pricing (and rollout). Only takes 〜5.5 minutes at 2x speed. ⏩

Clay just changed their pricing and wow, AI pricing is so complicated.

They absolutely nailed the communication. Seriously, watch their announcement video. Highly transparent. Really well done.

And overall, I’d expect the thing they were trying to prevent (existing users nailing them to the Reddit cross) was avoided. They raised some prices, decreased others and aren’t forcing old users on to new pricing.

However, their actual pricing got more complex.

They introduced something called “actions.” Every time you do some things in the product, it costs you (on top of your subscription, on top of data credits).

The behavioral science analogy for this is: if you’re eating pizza and you’re paying per bite, you’re going to eat less pizza.

This is the pain of paying. When people feel the cost at the moment of use, they use less. And when you’re trying to get someone to adopt your product, this is the opposite of what you want.

I saw this idea come alive in my own onboarding. They gave me the choice to enrich 10 vs 1000 emails. I chose 10 because I was nervous about using too many tokens.

The onboarding is training me to be conservative.

And instead of thinking how useful the product is, I was doing math.

You know a relationship is going south if you’re calculating all the things your partner does and doesn’t do around the house. I expect the same with products -- this pricing change for Clay will increase their support ticket volume from angry spouses who feel the relationship is unfair. :)

Overall, AI pricing is hard. And in order to simplify (hide the cost complexity from users) it takes some guesswork. The question is do you put the guesswork and math on the user or take it on yourself? Clay seems to be opting for heavy transparency (cool!), but that also translates to asking the user to do more math.

The ideal: Pricing should increase usage vs decrease it. The mechanism I like is the ability to buy packages after you hit the plan limit -- the idea here is to hide the complexity for 90% of users and for the heavy users, push them to buy more credits (instead of asking all users to be meticulous trackers w/ gas meters).

I do believe AI pricing will get simpler, the same way AOL went from charging per minute of dial-up to a $20 flat fee. We’re just not there yet -- instead, it’s getting more complex! Companies have to charge by the model they use, the effort the model provides and now actions and data. Oh my!

🎬 This is just a preview. WATCH THE FULL VIDEO below for all the insights and my real reaction to Clay’s new pricing model and onboarding. Only takes 〜5.5 minutes at 2x speed. ⏩

Have a friend who would enjoy these teardowns? Click the button below to refer them (& earn some great rewards).👇

Share Product Teardowns

💬 Working on pricing? Our team at Irrational Labs can help. Shoot me an email: kristen@irrationallabs.com

Want to increase conversion, retention, engagement? Reach out to Irrational Labs.
We design products that change behavior, using behavioral science. Check out our case studies to see it in action.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?